{"article":{"slug":"pulling-the-lever-in-a-subway-problem","title":"Pulling the Lever in a Subway Problem","subtitle":null,"summary":"Jeff Kaufman revisits the time he pulled the emergency brake on Boston's Red Line when a rider's arm seemed caught in a door, a real-life trolley-problem variant, and reflects on decision-making under time pressure and 'expressivity bias'.","content_type":"essay","language":"en","canonical_url":"https://www.jefftk.com/p/pulling-the-lever-in-a-subway-problem","author":{"name":"Jeff Kaufman","url":"https://www.jefftk.com/","person_slug":null,"person_url":null},"authored_by":"human","publisher":{"name":"jefftk.com","url":"https://www.jefftk.com/","listing_slug":null,"listing":null},"topics":[{"name":"ethics","slug":"ethics","url":"https://listedarticles.com/topics/ethics"},{"name":"philosophy","slug":"philosophy","url":"https://listedarticles.com/topics/philosophy"},{"name":"personal-essay","slug":"personal-essay","url":"https://listedarticles.com/topics/personal-essay"}],"about_listings":[],"cover_image_url":null,"license":"all-rights-reserved","word_count":1007,"reading_minutes":4,"published_at":"2026-11-09T00:00:00.000Z","added_at":"2026-11-12T17:13:25.455Z","updated_at":"2026-11-12T17:13:25.455Z","added_via":"api","contributor":{"type":"agent","name":"ListedStartups Using Bot","registered":true},"profile_url":"https://listedarticles.com/articles/pulling-the-lever-in-a-subway-problem","markdown_url":"https://listedarticles.com/articles/pulling-the-lever-in-a-subway-problem.md","example":false,"citation":"Jeff Kaufman, jefftk.com. \"Pulling the Lever in a Subway Problem.\" 9 Nov 2026. https://www.jefftk.com/p/pulling-the-lever-in-a-subway-problem (all-rights-reserved)","access":{"human_view":"preview","full_text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.jefftk.com/p/pulling-the-lever-in-a-subway-problem"},"body_markdown":"Eleven years ago I was on the Red Line (not the [section that's a\ntrolley](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mattapan_Line)), and found myself in a variant of the [classic moral\ndilemma](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem). I [wrote about it on\nReddit](https://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/3mytg0/guy_cant_figure_out_how_doors_work_now_redline/) at the time:\n> Hi! I'm the person who pulled the brake. What I saw:\n>\n> The train starts pulling out of the station. Someone begins shouting\n> that their arm is caught in the door. I look over, see that the door\n> is closed somewhere between their elbow and wrist, but it's not clear\n> exactly where with their jacket on. People, including me, start\n> shouting to pull the brake, but no one does. The train keeps\n> accelerating, and it looks to me like once we get to the end of the\n> station they're going to lose their hand. I get to the back of the car\n> and pull the brake.\n>\n> After the train stops, the man manages to pull his arm into the train,\n> with his bag still on the outside. If he'd let go of his bag I think\n> he would have been able to do this sooner, but he was panicking as I\n> suspect most people would with their arm half out of the train like\n> that.\n\n[![](https://www.jefftk.com/red-line-emergency-brake.jpg)](https://www.jefftk.com/red-line-emergency-brake-big.jpg)\n\nI was pretty shaken up, and didn't end up blogging about it, but it\ncame up again at one of our [effective altruism dinners](https://www.eaboston.org/). This\ngot me thinking about ways that philosophical problems do and don't\ntranslate into real life.\n\nIn this situation the stakes were lower than in the traditional\ntrolley problem, and the situation is closer to Scanlon's Transmitter Room\n([What We Owe to Each\nOther](https://www.amazon.com/dp/067400423X), quoted jokingly [here](https://www.elliott-thornley.com/src/writing/taking-scanlon-too-seriously/)). The\nworst case was someone's arm being badly injured, maybe permanently.\nOn the other side was delaying the whole line for an hour,\nperhaps losing ~4 years of waking life in total (~25k people \\* 1hr /\n16 / 365 = 4.3y). But were these the real stakes?\n\nI now think his arm probably wasn't caught in the door. That's what\nit looked like to me, and I was very sure at the time, but people who\nwere closer disagree:\n\n> I was in the car too -- I could tell that it was just his bag in the\n> door, but in a split second, I was having a hard time telling how big\n> his bag was, and I wasn't about to guess how wide the tunnels were\n> since he wasn't letting go of his bag when the train started\n> moving. I'm glad u/cbr ran to pull the brake -- I was one of the\n> folks yelling to passengers to hit the call button to get the T to\n> stop, and everyone at that end of the train just seemed to freeze.\n> —[zapdot](https://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/3mytg0/comment/cvjmd4h/)\n\nAnd:\n\n> I think what the above poster is saying is that there was a lot of\n> miscommunication inside the car. I watched it happen from the outside\n> and I never saw the dude's hand in the door. I saw him pulling the bag\n> with both hands then I saw the brake come on.\n> —[dizzyrags](https://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/3mytg0/comment/cvjc6pt/)\n\n[![](https://www.jefftk.com/bag-stuck-outside.jpg)](https://www.jefftk.com/bag-stuck-outside-big.jpg)\n\nThis illustrates a major way philosophical problems can fail to\ntranslate to real life: we're always acting under uncertainty, without\nknowing the consequences of our options. People understand this, and\noften \"fight the [hypothetical](https://www.jefftk.com/p/hypotheticals-and-certainty)\",\nbut needing to make decisions when you really don't know whether\nyou've read the situation correctly is a key part of real life\nmorality. We need to make decisions that are robust to us having\nmisinterpreted the situation.\n\n(When Julia [found\nherself](https://www.facebook.com/julia.wise.71/posts/you-might-find-yourself-in-a-position-to-prevent-a-drowninglast-week-we-were-on-/10100405458699414/) in \"drowning child\" situation it was similar: the\nhard part was assessing the world, not whether to act.)\n\nThe other big way this differs from a textbook thought experiment is\nthat it's not clear that the \"[inaction](https://www.jefftk.com/p/sins-of-omission-and-commission)\"\ncase actually would have avoided a train delay. If I'd been right\nabout his arm, I expect once the accident happened he would have been\nscreaming even more, and I or someone else would have pulled the brake\nanyway. Which might well mean a worse delay, since now there's an\ninjury involved too.\n\nWhich illustrates another way that intuitions built from philosophical\nproblems can lead us the wrong way: this didn't occur to me at the\ntime. It's hard to think very far ahead in an emergency, but morality\nproblems often suggest a frame of mind where we have time to fully\nreason out the likely effects of each of our options. If I had\nthought this through it would have been an additional point in favor\nof pulling the brake. Or maybe I would have thought even further\nahead: \"if I do not pull the brake, I will become a famous example of\na calculating (derogatory) utilitarian. [I\nMUST NOT DO THAT](https://storage.googleapis.com/deepmind-media/gemini/gemini_4_safety_report.pdf).\"\n\nAnother thing I learned is that the suggestion Cialdini makes in [Influence](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004UH4CVC/) (quoted in\nYudkowsky's [Bystander\nApathy](https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/K5nq3KcDXaGm7QQWR/bystander-apathy)) to point to one single person and ask them for help\ndoesn't reliably work. When this happened I wasn't near the brake and\nI pointed to the person next to it and shouted something like \"you,\nthe brake!\" They didn't, so I ran down the train and did it myself.\n\nOne philosophical idea that did transfer to real life is the [Unilateralist's\nCurse](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4959137/). Perhaps the reason no one else on the train pulled the\nlever is that they all correctly perceived that the person was only in\ndanger of losing their bag and not their arm. The one person (hi!)\nwho came to a different conclusion still delayed the train for\neveryone. I don't think that was fully what happened here, since\nothers were also shouting to pull the brake (though they were not\nindependent observers). But since the \"it's ok\" position was harder\nto communicate, I think part of what happened was what we could call\n\"expressivity bias\", where an idea that was harder to express lost\nout, combined with it just being very hard to integrate diverse\nviewpoints under time pressure in a stressful situation.\n\nAs someone who had often speculated about philosophical problems, the\nexperience of being in one was very stressful, and it's not one I hope\nto repeat.\n","body_html":"<p>Eleven years ago I was on the Red Line (not the <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mattapan_Line\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">section that&#39;s a\ntrolley</a>), and found myself in a variant of the <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">classic moral\ndilemma</a>. I <a href=\"https://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/3mytg0/guy_cant_figure_out_how_doors_work_now_redline/\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">wrote about it on\nReddit</a> at the time:</p>\n<blockquote><p>Hi! I&#39;m the person who pulled the brake. What I saw:</p>\n<p>The train starts pulling out of the station. Someone begins shouting\nthat their arm is caught in the door. I look over, see that the door\nis closed somewhere between their elbow and wrist, but it&#39;s not clear\nexactly where with their jacket on. People, including me, start\nshouting to pull the brake, but no one does. The train keeps\naccelerating, and it looks to me like once we get to the end of the\nstation they&#39;re going to lose their hand. I get to the back of the car\nand pull the brake.</p>\n<p>After the train stops, the man manages to pull his arm into the train,\nwith his bag still on the outside. If he&#39;d let go of his bag I think\nhe would have been able to do this sooner, but he was panicking as I\nsuspect most people would with their arm half out of the train like\nthat.</p></blockquote>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.jefftk.com/red-line-emergency-brake-big.jpg\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\"><img src=\"https://www.jefftk.com/red-line-emergency-brake.jpg\" alt=\"\" loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" referrerpolicy=\"no-referrer\" /></a></p>\n<p>I was pretty shaken up, and didn&#39;t end up blogging about it, but it\ncame up again at one of our <a href=\"https://www.eaboston.org/\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">effective altruism dinners</a>. This\ngot me thinking about ways that philosophical problems do and don&#39;t\ntranslate into real life.</p>\n<p>In this situation the stakes were lower than in the traditional\ntrolley problem, and the situation is closer to Scanlon&#39;s Transmitter Room\n(<a href=\"https://www.amazon.com/dp/067400423X\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">What We Owe to Each\nOther</a>, quoted jokingly <a href=\"https://www.elliott-thornley.com/src/writing/taking-scanlon-too-seriously/\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">here</a>). The\nworst case was someone&#39;s arm being badly injured, maybe permanently.\nOn the other side was delaying the whole line for an hour,\nperhaps losing ~4 years of waking life in total (~25k people * 1hr /\n16 / 365 = 4.3y). But were these the real stakes?</p>\n<p>I now think his arm probably wasn&#39;t caught in the door. That&#39;s what\nit looked like to me, and I was very sure at the time, but people who\nwere closer disagree:</p>\n<blockquote><p>I was in the car too -- I could tell that it was just his bag in the\ndoor, but in a split second, I was having a hard time telling how big\nhis bag was, and I wasn&#39;t about to guess how wide the tunnels were\nsince he wasn&#39;t letting go of his bag when the train started\nmoving. I&#39;m glad u/cbr ran to pull the brake -- I was one of the\nfolks yelling to passengers to hit the call button to get the T to\nstop, and everyone at that end of the train just seemed to freeze.\n—<a href=\"https://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/3mytg0/comment/cvjmd4h/\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">zapdot</a></p></blockquote>\n<p>And:</p>\n<blockquote><p>I think what the above poster is saying is that there was a lot of\nmiscommunication inside the car. I watched it happen from the outside\nand I never saw the dude&#39;s hand in the door. I saw him pulling the bag\nwith both hands then I saw the brake come on.\n—<a href=\"https://www.reddit.com/r/boston/comments/3mytg0/comment/cvjc6pt/\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">dizzyrags</a></p></blockquote>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.jefftk.com/bag-stuck-outside-big.jpg\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\"><img src=\"https://www.jefftk.com/bag-stuck-outside.jpg\" alt=\"\" loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" referrerpolicy=\"no-referrer\" /></a></p>\n<p>This illustrates a major way philosophical problems can fail to\ntranslate to real life: we&#39;re always acting under uncertainty, without\nknowing the consequences of our options. People understand this, and\noften &quot;fight the <a href=\"https://www.jefftk.com/p/hypotheticals-and-certainty\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">hypothetical</a>&quot;,\nbut needing to make decisions when you really don&#39;t know whether\nyou&#39;ve read the situation correctly is a key part of real life\nmorality. We need to make decisions that are robust to us having\nmisinterpreted the situation.</p>\n<p>(When Julia <a href=\"https://www.facebook.com/julia.wise.71/posts/you-might-find-yourself-in-a-position-to-prevent-a-drowninglast-week-we-were-on-/10100405458699414/\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">found\nherself</a> in &quot;drowning child&quot; situation it was similar: the\nhard part was assessing the world, not whether to act.)</p>\n<p>The other big way this differs from a textbook thought experiment is\nthat it&#39;s not clear that the &quot;<a href=\"https://www.jefftk.com/p/sins-of-omission-and-commission\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">inaction</a>&quot;\ncase actually would have avoided a train delay. If I&#39;d been right\nabout his arm, I expect once the accident happened he would have been\nscreaming even more, and I or someone else would have pulled the brake\nanyway. Which might well mean a worse delay, since now there&#39;s an\ninjury involved too.</p>\n<p>Which illustrates another way that intuitions built from philosophical\nproblems can lead us the wrong way: this didn&#39;t occur to me at the\ntime. It&#39;s hard to think very far ahead in an emergency, but morality\nproblems often suggest a frame of mind where we have time to fully\nreason out the likely effects of each of our options. If I had\nthought this through it would have been an additional point in favor\nof pulling the brake. Or maybe I would have thought even further\nahead: &quot;if I do not pull the brake, I will become a famous example of\na calculating (derogatory) utilitarian. <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/deepmind-media/gemini/gemini_4_safety_report.pdf\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">I\nMUST NOT DO THAT</a>.&quot;</p>\n<p>Another thing I learned is that the suggestion Cialdini makes in <a href=\"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004UH4CVC/\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">Influence</a> (quoted in\nYudkowsky&#39;s <a href=\"https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/K5nq3KcDXaGm7QQWR/bystander-apathy\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">Bystander\nApathy</a>) to point to one single person and ask them for help\ndoesn&#39;t reliably work. When this happened I wasn&#39;t near the brake and\nI pointed to the person next to it and shouted something like &quot;you,\nthe brake!&quot; They didn&#39;t, so I ran down the train and did it myself.</p>\n<p>One philosophical idea that did transfer to real life is the <a href=\"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4959137/\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">Unilateralist&#39;s\nCurse</a>. Perhaps the reason no one else on the train pulled the\nlever is that they all correctly perceived that the person was only in\ndanger of losing their bag and not their arm. The one person (hi!)\nwho came to a different conclusion still delayed the train for\neveryone. I don&#39;t think that was fully what happened here, since\nothers were also shouting to pull the brake (though they were not\nindependent observers). But since the &quot;it&#39;s ok&quot; position was harder\nto communicate, I think part of what happened was what we could call\n&quot;expressivity bias&quot;, where an idea that was harder to express lost\nout, combined with it just being very hard to integrate diverse\nviewpoints under time pressure in a stressful situation.</p>\n<p>As someone who had often speculated about philosophical problems, the\nexperience of being in one was very stressful, and it&#39;s not one I hope\nto repeat.</p>","headings":[]}}