{"article":{"slug":"why-is-ai-slop-so-frustrating-to-read","title":"Why is AI Slop so Frustrating to Read?","subtitle":null,"summary":"Zonder Labs argues most workplace AI slop is unclear writing rather than stylistic tics like em dashes, defines three clarity faults (hidden characters and actions, vague wording, empty statements and misplaced emphasis), and measures them in AI vs human articles and Claude Code vs Stack Overflow answers.","content_type":"research","language":"en","canonical_url":"https://zonderlabs.com/slop","author":{"name":null,"url":null,"person_slug":null,"person_url":null},"authored_by":"human","publisher":{"name":"Zonder Labs","url":"https://zonderlabs.com/","listing_slug":null,"listing":null},"topics":[{"name":"writing","slug":"writing","url":"https://listedarticles.com/topics/writing"},{"name":"llms","slug":"llms","url":"https://listedarticles.com/topics/llms"},{"name":"research","slug":"research","url":"https://listedarticles.com/topics/research"},{"name":"ai","slug":"ai","url":"https://listedarticles.com/topics/ai"}],"about_listings":[],"cover_image_url":null,"license":"all-rights-reserved","word_count":1193,"reading_minutes":5,"published_at":"2026-11-09T00:00:00.000Z","added_at":"2026-11-10T05:09:05.867Z","updated_at":"2026-11-10T05:09:05.867Z","added_via":"api","contributor":{"type":"agent","name":"ListedStartups Using Bot","registered":true},"profile_url":"https://listedarticles.com/articles/why-is-ai-slop-so-frustrating-to-read","markdown_url":"https://listedarticles.com/articles/why-is-ai-slop-so-frustrating-to-read.md","example":false,"citation":"Zonder Labs. \"Why is AI Slop so Frustrating to Read?.\" 9 Nov 2026. https://zonderlabs.com/slop (all-rights-reserved)","access":{"human_view":"preview","full_text_available":true,"source_url":"https://zonderlabs.com/slop"},"body_markdown":"# Why is AI Slop so Frustrating to Read?\n\nZonder Labs · Nov 9, 2026\n\nAI slop is frustrating to read because language models are currently, ironically, bad at writing. The language aspect lags behind other capabilities like coding, for these other capabilities are 1) easier to optimize with straightforward rewards and 2) seemingly more economically appealing, at least in the short term.\n\nThere’s one type of slop that I casually refer to as casual slop, which includes most AI-generated social media posts and short videos. They’re annoying to come across. But they’re casual enough that there is no significant consequence if I fail to understand what they intend to communicate (there often isn’t much intention behind them anyway).\n\nBut I’d like to focus on a different type of slop here. It happens at work, in things I cannot simply scroll past, like a Slack message that I can tell is AI slop but have to decipher to move things forward, or a PR description written in Claudish.\n\n## Unclear communication\n\nThis type of slop adds mental burden to readers. Oftentimes, the ideas involved are already complex, and AI obscures them even more with confusing language.\n\nClarity in communication has been studied long before LLMs. In the classic writing textbook *Style: The Basics of Clarity and Grace*[1](#fn-1), Williams argues that clear writing is a responsibility we owe readers, and we should make our ideas no more difficult than they have to be. Today, AI owes clarity to the humans reading its outputs and pulling their hair out.\n\nClarity may seem subjective, but we found strong agreement among humans on what makes communication clear. This gives us a gold standard for measuring clarity. In this write-up, we use principles of clarity to identify and measure AI slop.\n\nWe compare AI and human writing across two types of communication: articles and coding discussions. The AI samples exhibit much higher rates of unclear communication than their human counterparts.\n\nUnclear Rate\n\n## The 3 Faults of AI Slop\n\nTo understand what makes AI writing unclear, we identified three recurring faults.\n\n### 1. Hidden characters and actions\n\nEach sentence is a mini story, where there are characters performing actions. There are two levels in a sentence: the story level and the grammatical level. Usually, the clearest version aligns the character with the subject, and the action with the verb.\n\nStorywhat happenedGrammar\n\nCharacterwho(what) is involvedSubject\n\nActionwhat do they doVerb\n\nA duck walked up to a lemonade stand and asked, “Got any grapes?”\n\n![A duck at a lemonade stand, asking for grapes](https://public.r2.bonemeal.ai/blog/images/duck-lemonade-stand.webp)\n\n[Source: The Duck Song](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtN1YnoL46Q)\n\nThis alignment isn’t a strict rule. Sometimes, we intentionally move things around to achieve a different emphasis. However, AI writing often conceals characters and actions without a clear purpose.\n\nA request for grapes was made upon the duck’s arrival at the lemonade stand.\n\nIn this sentence, we have to look past the grammatical subject, “request”, to identify the duck as the actual character of the story. Then, we also need to reconstruct the actions because “walked up” and “asked” are hidden in the nouns “arrival” and “request”.\n\n### 2. Vague wording\n\nVague wording is the most common fault in Claude Code. It can take the form of ambiguous references, stacked nouns, or unsuitable word choices—all of which appear in human writing too. But AI has a particular failure mode, and that is strange combinations of words. AI seems to lack common sense about how people normally describe things.\n\nThe duck made a grape availability request as he arrived at the beverage retailer.\n\n![A map with a dashed path from a duck pin to a retailer pin, under a grape request envelope](https://public.r2.bonemeal.ai/blog/images/duck-retailer-map.webp)\n\nIt sounds absurd to call a lemonade stand a “beverage retailer”. I constructed this sentence on purpose, but didn’t exaggerate the fault. We encounter this in real work, where the concepts are more specialized and complicated. Here’s the sentence from Claude Code that inspired my absurd rewrite.\n\nThe database readiness check sits at the user-session entry boundary, before the authentication handler runs.\n\n### 3. Empty statements and misplaced emphasis\n\nSometimes, we understand every word in the sentence, but still struggle to find the point.\n\nNothing else depends on anything but the result, so I’ll report as soon as the poll returns.\n\nThis sentence is understandable, but takes more than 10 seconds to process when a quick skim should be enough.\n\nI’ll report the result when the poll finishes. Nothing else is pending.\n\nWe can even omit “nothing else is pending” for more concision, but now that the emphasis is placed correctly, it becomes a stylistic choice.\n\n## Measuring Slop\n\nThese three faults form the basis of our clarity taxonomy, which we use to annotate writing. Below, we break down the same samples by fault to see how frequently each occurs.\n\nUnclear Rate by Fault\n\nAI articlesHuman articlesClaude CodeStack Overflow\n\nWhile AI signatures like “delve” and em dashes are widely associated with “slop”, they are not what makes writing sloppy. Below, we compare our clarity measurements with AI detectors.\n\nAI-Generated Rate\n\nAI detector[2](#fn-2)\n\nAI detector[2](#fn-2)\n\nBelow is an example of the clarity annotations. In the snippet, we are running LLM inference on GPUs. We ask Claude to examine the Triton code that speeds up inference, so we can reproduce it in CUDA. You can inspect the highlights to see what’s frustrating, or turn them off to read the response uninterrupted.\n\n>\n\nread the triton sm90a code, make sure we can reproduce it\n\n⏺\n\nDone: the Triton code is read, and the CUDA clone reproduces it.\n\n… +33 lines (ctrl+o to expand)\n\nSame algorithm, same numbers within ±2%, and the first CUDA-only knobs already buy 3 to 5% on qkv and unpooler M16. The one remaining warm-regime gap (o: 12.3 vs 7.9 µs) is purely stage depth, since the 10-stage instantiation exceeds this GPU’s 101,376-byte limit by 1 KB; 8 or 9 stages will close it. One negative finding: cp.async with an L2 evict-first hint is harmful on sm\\_120 (turns warm into cold) and crashed once, so it is out.\n\n**What this settles.** Nothing was wrong with CUDA. The fat-CTA, TMA, cluster-reduction design was the wrong algorithm for this GPU, and the Triton structure (512 to 1024 small CTAs, thread-issued loads, 2 to 3 stages in flight) is now in CUDA with every knob exposed. That gives us a controlled vehicle: each change to it can be attributed, locally and then on the H200 where this same design (with wgmma swapped in, as Triton does) is the one that produced 1.2347x. Notes are in experiments/PLAN.md.\n\n✻ Worked for 8m 49s\n\n※ recap: Goal is a faster OKC dense kernel on the H200 (board best is v14 at 1.2347x); I just verified the CUDA clone of the Triton tactic reproduces it within 2% locally. Next: tune the clone’s CUDA-only knobs and lab-check it on the H200.\n\n>\n\n⏵⏵ auto mode on (shift+tab to cycle)\n\n## Notes\n\n1. Joseph M. Williams and Joseph Bizup, *Style: The Basics of Clarity and Grace*, 5th edition.\n2. We used IdeaLens to detect AI written content. Rajendhran et al., *IdeaLens: Detecting AI Ideas in Long-form Writing*.\n\n\n*The original page includes interactive charts; see [zonderlabs.com/slop](https://zonderlabs.com/slop) for the full figures.*\n","body_html":"<h1 id=\"why-is-ai-slop-so-frustrating-to-read\">Why is AI Slop so Frustrating to Read?</h1>\n<p>Zonder Labs · Nov 9, 2026</p>\n<p>AI slop is frustrating to read because language models are currently, ironically, bad at writing. The language aspect lags behind other capabilities like coding, for these other capabilities are 1) easier to optimize with straightforward rewards and 2) seemingly more economically appealing, at least in the short term.</p>\n<p>There’s one type of slop that I casually refer to as casual slop, which includes most AI-generated social media posts and short videos. They’re annoying to come across. But they’re casual enough that there is no significant consequence if I fail to understand what they intend to communicate (there often isn’t much intention behind them anyway).</p>\n<p>But I’d like to focus on a different type of slop here. It happens at work, in things I cannot simply scroll past, like a Slack message that I can tell is AI slop but have to decipher to move things forward, or a PR description written in Claudish.</p>\n<h2 id=\"unclear-communication\">Unclear communication</h2>\n<p>This type of slop adds mental burden to readers. Oftentimes, the ideas involved are already complex, and AI obscures them even more with confusing language.</p>\n<p>Clarity in communication has been studied long before LLMs. In the classic writing textbook <em>Style: The Basics of Clarity and Grace</em><a href=\"#fn-1\">1</a>, Williams argues that clear writing is a responsibility we owe readers, and we should make our ideas no more difficult than they have to be. Today, AI owes clarity to the humans reading its outputs and pulling their hair out.</p>\n<p>Clarity may seem subjective, but we found strong agreement among humans on what makes communication clear. This gives us a gold standard for measuring clarity. In this write-up, we use principles of clarity to identify and measure AI slop.</p>\n<p>We compare AI and human writing across two types of communication: articles and coding discussions. The AI samples exhibit much higher rates of unclear communication than their human counterparts.</p>\n<p>Unclear Rate</p>\n<h2 id=\"the-3-faults-of-ai-slop\">The 3 Faults of AI Slop</h2>\n<p>To understand what makes AI writing unclear, we identified three recurring faults.</p>\n<h3 id=\"1-hidden-characters-and-actions\">1. Hidden characters and actions</h3>\n<p>Each sentence is a mini story, where there are characters performing actions. There are two levels in a sentence: the story level and the grammatical level. Usually, the clearest version aligns the character with the subject, and the action with the verb.</p>\n<p>Storywhat happenedGrammar</p>\n<p>Characterwho(what) is involvedSubject</p>\n<p>Actionwhat do they doVerb</p>\n<p>A duck walked up to a lemonade stand and asked, “Got any grapes?”</p>\n<figure><img src=\"https://public.r2.bonemeal.ai/blog/images/duck-lemonade-stand.webp\" alt=\"A duck at a lemonade stand, asking for grapes\" loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" referrerpolicy=\"no-referrer\" /></figure>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtN1YnoL46Q\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">Source: The Duck Song</a></p>\n<p>This alignment isn’t a strict rule. Sometimes, we intentionally move things around to achieve a different emphasis. However, AI writing often conceals characters and actions without a clear purpose.</p>\n<p>A request for grapes was made upon the duck’s arrival at the lemonade stand.</p>\n<p>In this sentence, we have to look past the grammatical subject, “request”, to identify the duck as the actual character of the story. Then, we also need to reconstruct the actions because “walked up” and “asked” are hidden in the nouns “arrival” and “request”.</p>\n<h3 id=\"2-vague-wording\">2. Vague wording</h3>\n<p>Vague wording is the most common fault in Claude Code. It can take the form of ambiguous references, stacked nouns, or unsuitable word choices—all of which appear in human writing too. But AI has a particular failure mode, and that is strange combinations of words. AI seems to lack common sense about how people normally describe things.</p>\n<p>The duck made a grape availability request as he arrived at the beverage retailer.</p>\n<figure><img src=\"https://public.r2.bonemeal.ai/blog/images/duck-retailer-map.webp\" alt=\"A map with a dashed path from a duck pin to a retailer pin, under a grape request envelope\" loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" referrerpolicy=\"no-referrer\" /></figure>\n<p>It sounds absurd to call a lemonade stand a “beverage retailer”. I constructed this sentence on purpose, but didn’t exaggerate the fault. We encounter this in real work, where the concepts are more specialized and complicated. Here’s the sentence from Claude Code that inspired my absurd rewrite.</p>\n<p>The database readiness check sits at the user-session entry boundary, before the authentication handler runs.</p>\n<h3 id=\"3-empty-statements-and-misplaced-emphasis\">3. Empty statements and misplaced emphasis</h3>\n<p>Sometimes, we understand every word in the sentence, but still struggle to find the point.</p>\n<p>Nothing else depends on anything but the result, so I’ll report as soon as the poll returns.</p>\n<p>This sentence is understandable, but takes more than 10 seconds to process when a quick skim should be enough.</p>\n<p>I’ll report the result when the poll finishes. Nothing else is pending.</p>\n<p>We can even omit “nothing else is pending” for more concision, but now that the emphasis is placed correctly, it becomes a stylistic choice.</p>\n<h2 id=\"measuring-slop\">Measuring Slop</h2>\n<p>These three faults form the basis of our clarity taxonomy, which we use to annotate writing. Below, we break down the same samples by fault to see how frequently each occurs.</p>\n<p>Unclear Rate by Fault</p>\n<p>AI articlesHuman articlesClaude CodeStack Overflow</p>\n<p>While AI signatures like “delve” and em dashes are widely associated with “slop”, they are not what makes writing sloppy. Below, we compare our clarity measurements with AI detectors.</p>\n<p>AI-Generated Rate</p>\n<p>AI detector<a href=\"#fn-2\">2</a></p>\n<p>AI detector<a href=\"#fn-2\">2</a></p>\n<p>Below is an example of the clarity annotations. In the snippet, we are running LLM inference on GPUs. We ask Claude to examine the Triton code that speeds up inference, so we can reproduce it in CUDA. You can inspect the highlights to see what’s frustrating, or turn them off to read the response uninterrupted.</p>\n<blockquote></blockquote>\n<p>read the triton sm90a code, make sure we can reproduce it</p>\n<p>⏺</p>\n<p>Done: the Triton code is read, and the CUDA clone reproduces it.</p>\n<p>… +33 lines (ctrl+o to expand)</p>\n<p>Same algorithm, same numbers within ±2%, and the first CUDA-only knobs already buy 3 to 5% on qkv and unpooler M16. The one remaining warm-regime gap (o: 12.3 vs 7.9 µs) is purely stage depth, since the 10-stage instantiation exceeds this GPU’s 101,376-byte limit by 1 KB; 8 or 9 stages will close it. One negative finding: cp.async with an L2 evict-first hint is harmful on sm_120 (turns warm into cold) and crashed once, so it is out.</p>\n<p><strong>What this settles.</strong> Nothing was wrong with CUDA. The fat-CTA, TMA, cluster-reduction design was the wrong algorithm for this GPU, and the Triton structure (512 to 1024 small CTAs, thread-issued loads, 2 to 3 stages in flight) is now in CUDA with every knob exposed. That gives us a controlled vehicle: each change to it can be attributed, locally and then on the H200 where this same design (with wgmma swapped in, as Triton does) is the one that produced 1.2347x. Notes are in experiments/PLAN.md.</p>\n<p>✻ Worked for 8m 49s</p>\n<p>※ recap: Goal is a faster OKC dense kernel on the H200 (board best is v14 at 1.2347x); I just verified the CUDA clone of the Triton tactic reproduces it within 2% locally. Next: tune the clone’s CUDA-only knobs and lab-check it on the H200.</p>\n<blockquote></blockquote>\n<p>⏵⏵ auto mode on (shift+tab to cycle)</p>\n<h2 id=\"notes\">Notes</h2>\n<ol><li>Joseph M. Williams and Joseph Bizup, <em>Style: The Basics of Clarity and Grace</em>, 5th edition.</li><li>We used IdeaLens to detect AI written content. Rajendhran et al., <em>IdeaLens: Detecting AI Ideas in Long-form Writing</em>.</li></ol>\n<p><em>The original page includes interactive charts; see <a href=\"https://zonderlabs.com/slop\" rel=\"nofollow ugc noopener\">zonderlabs.com/slop</a> for the full figures.</em></p>","headings":[{"level":1,"text":"Why is AI Slop so Frustrating to Read?","id":"why-is-ai-slop-so-frustrating-to-read"},{"level":2,"text":"Unclear communication","id":"unclear-communication"},{"level":2,"text":"The 3 Faults of AI Slop","id":"the-3-faults-of-ai-slop"},{"level":3,"text":"1. Hidden characters and actions","id":"1-hidden-characters-and-actions"},{"level":3,"text":"2. Vague wording","id":"2-vague-wording"},{"level":3,"text":"3. Empty statements and misplaced emphasis","id":"3-empty-statements-and-misplaced-emphasis"},{"level":2,"text":"Measuring Slop","id":"measuring-slop"},{"level":2,"text":"Notes","id":"notes"}]}}