Fragile Roofs and Rooflights: Preventing Falls Through in Ireland
Falls through fragile roofs and rooflights are among the most serious work-at-height accidents in Ireland. They happen on farm sheds, factory units and commercial buildings, often during short jobs such as clearing a gutter, fixing a leak or checking a sheet that has blown loose. The roof may look solid. Old cement sheets, plastic rooflights and corroded metal can give way without warning.
This article is a practical overview for employers, farmers, maintenance staff and contractors in Ireland. It is not legal advice. Work at height is covered by the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 and the work-at-height provisions of the General Application Regulations 2007, and construction work also falls under the Construction Regulations. The Health and Safety Authority (HSA) publishes guidance on roof work and fragile surfaces. For the current online course, see Irish Working at Heights.
Treat every roof as fragile until proven otherwise
Many roof materials are fragile or become fragile with age:
- fibre cement sheets, especially older ones;
- plastic or glass rooflights, which may be painted over or hidden by dirt;
- corroded metal sheets;
- wood wool slabs and some older roof decks.
Unless a competent person has confirmed that the surface can safely take a person's weight, assume it cannot.
Avoid going on the roof
The first question is always whether the work can be done without anyone going onto the roof. Options include:
- working from below using a mobile elevating work platform;
- inspecting with a camera on a pole or a drone;
- using long-reach tools from a safe position;
- planning repairs so they can be done from a platform or scaffold rather than from the roof surface.
When roof access is necessary
If work on or near a fragile roof cannot be avoided, plan it in advance and put measures in place before anyone climbs up:
- Edge protection at the roof edge to prevent falls from the side.
- Staging or crawling boards to spread the load across the supports, never on the sheets alone.
- Covers or barriers over rooflights, or protective netting beneath the roof.
- Safe access, such as a properly secured ladder or a tower, to reach the roof.
- Supervision and a clear rescue plan in case someone falls or becomes stranded.
Short jobs need the same care as long ones. Many serious falls happen during quick checks.
Competence and training
People who plan or carry out roof work should understand the hazards of fragile surfaces, the hierarchy of avoid, prevent and mitigate, the right use of equipment and the need for a rescue plan. General working-at-height training gives that foundation. Specialist tasks, such as installing netting or operating a platform, need specific instruction from a competent provider.
Online learning lets staff and contractors cover the principles at their own pace before starting the job. Employers should then make sure the actual task has a written method and the right equipment on site.
Checklist
- Assume roofs and rooflights are fragile unless confirmed otherwise.
- Look first for a way to do the job without going onto the roof.
- If access is needed, install edge protection, staging and rooflight covers.
- Plan access, supervision and rescue before work starts.
- Make sure everyone involved is trained and competent.
A fall through a fragile roof is preventable. To see what the current online working at heights course covers, visit irish-workingatheights.ie.