When is a class a “commodity” and when does it depend on the instructor?

Sometimes I get emails from students asking to work on a project with me, and I usually respond that they should take one of my classes first. If they try to work on a project without having taken a class first, I usually end up having to teach them a bunch of things. Sure, they could read my books, but I guess people don’t really like to read, also there’s something extra you get from hearing it live, doing the homework, getting feedback in class, etc.

This always puzzled me, that students would think they could jump in a project without taking any of my classes first . . . but then I realized that it’s usual to think of a math class as being pretty much the same no matter who teaches it. You take calculus or linear algebra or real analysis or whatever, and it can be taught well or poorly, there are good teachers and bad teachers, but they’re pretty much all teaching the same thing.