To the faculty who have been organizing against AI: you are fighting the wrong technology. While you’re writing think pieces about “cognitive offloading” and “the importance of writing” on social media, you’re still using Canvas, Brightspace, and Blackboard to “deliver instruction” to your students.
You are not wrong to insist upon the principles of good teaching, like the importance of writing, human feedback, instilling a spirit of curiosity and discovery. But course management software, which ninety-nine percent of colleges and universities now use, violates all these principles.
Canvas (which I’ll use to mean all course management software) is a far, far more harmful technology than even the early, hallucinating LLMs. And yet the researchers who know the most about the horrors of Canvas, like Britt Paris, reserve terms like “terrified” and “onslaught” for AI alone. The AAUP’s 2025 report Artificial Intelligence and Academic Professions calls Canvas “a data-intensive tool that is synonymous with AI.” But it isn’t synonymous. Canvas is worse.
Canvas is a compliance tool, not a teaching tool. Universities like it because it organizes digital paperwork to be surveilled and reported to accreditors.1 It has zero educational value, which you cannot say about AI. You may be opposed to AI for any number of reasons, but you cannot say people do not learn things from it and with it. They do. Canvas, on the other hand, actively prevents learning.
This fall I found myself back in the classroom after a decade and I am aghast that students tell me their primary “interface” with their courses (even their in-person courses) is with a screen, not their professor. It’s not really in person. They get their assignments from Canvas, not the professor. They turn their assignments in to Canvas, not the professor. They get their grade from Canvas, not the professor. This has been normal for many of them through high school. Their education is already digitized and delivered through screens. So as long as they are already sitting at a keyboard, not reading a book in a classroom or holding a beaker in a lab, they might as well just open another tab and ask ChatGPT.
Who let the Canvas takeover happen? Why are there no organized protests? I was astounded to read that my primary adversary about AI here on Substack, John Warner, in a scalding critique after the Canvas hack in May, uses none of the vitriol he reserves for AI. He agrees Canvas is terrible and creates “an unintentional culture of passivity and disengagement,” but shrugs, as if there’s nothing he can do. The Chronicle had its own story of shrugging.
What is wrong with you people? Canvas is a far more dangerous and corrupting technology than AI. Want evidence? Here you go:
1. Canvas restricts how faculty teach and students learn. The platform is designed for thinking in “modules,” for breaking the course into digestible chunks that you serve to students such that “progress” can be monitored. Faculty re-use their course materials year after year after year without changing a word. You are worried about stochastic parrots? Canvas has turned America’s faculty into stochastic parrots.
2. Cognitive offloading! Students don’t have to remember anything because Canvas remembers for them. I asked my students if they mind how little I use Canvas and they said, “well we have to remember more about what we’re reading and we don’t know how we’re doing unless we ask you.” John Warner said it better, that Canvas produced a “culture of passivity and disengagement with the logistical requirements of the course.” There’s science too showing that with Canvas, students don’t encode or recall what they’re supposed to learn.
3. Invasion of student privacy! Canvas records every page your students open, every minute they stay, and every time they switch browser tabs during a quiz. The Nation published a brutal exposé in 2021 by Britt Paris and two colleagues that did not provoke protests. Britt—we still can and should rise up Students aren’t aware of any of this and aren’t given a chance to consent. Institutions claim that surveillance is supposed to help struggling students, but it only “establishes predictive feasibility,” according to a study.
And don’t forget the Canvas hack in May, which stole the names, email addresses, ID numbers, and private messages of 275 million Canvas users. (Did you know Canvas paid a ransom? Undisclosed amount, which they of course passed on to your institution.)
4. Did I mention invasion of privacy? All the classroom data—the grades, messages, and click histories—belong to private equity. In 2019 the then-CEO of Instructure (Canvas’s parent company) Dan Goldsmith told investors that the company holds “the most comprehensive database on the educational experience in the globe” and that “we will deliver and monetize it by offering different functional domains of predictive algorithms and insights.” In 2024 the private equity firm KKR bought Instructure (and “data assets” of “200 million learners”) for $4.8 billion in cash. Again, that means every message students sent to professors and you sent back, through Canvas, was part of the deal. It’s the same with Blackboard.
5. Canvas encourages student grade obsession! More than half of American teenagers check their grade portal at least once a day and two thirds say grades are the biggest stress in their lives. Gone are the days of students looking at the grades on their papers and quizzes and doing the calculation themselves, to figure out how hard to study for the final. Last October, an AWS outage locked students out for hours, causing panic.
Keep reading I’m going to say some uncomfortable things.
If you believe the fight to be waged today is between AI and human teaching, ask yourself why you have already consented to a compliance technology that boxes your students in, invades their privacy, and limits human contact? Why have you agreed to a technology that has spawned epic Reddit threads on clunkiness, lost hours on setup, inability to recognize math equations, flawed grading?
The reason faculty are not loudly protesting Canvas is that too many of you like the convenience and like being able to phone it in. This is absolutely true and nobody wants to admit it. But anecdotally, everyone reading this knows colleagues who say “I set my Canvas course shell up eight years ago and now I can take the whole summer off, because there’s nothing to prepare.” Or “I’m teaching six courses this semester—two in person and four online—for the extra cash. They basically run themselves on Canvas.” Or, “My university won’t let me assign a big, comprehensive textbook so I just .pdf’d the first three chapters, uploaded them, called it ‘student success,’ and nobody’s complaining, but they’re learning 1/3 the amount they should be.” Or, “You can replicate this course shell 1000 times and any teacher can teach it!”
I’ve written many times about bad teaching and ridiculously low standards and the stagnation and decay of what passes for a college education. Canvas is at the heart of pretty much all the problems.
Nobody is protesting Canvas because the laziest teachers love it. Canvas sells itself as a lazy-teaching technology. 10 Time-Saving Features! “Imagine creating a course once and sharing it with other educators teaching the same course.” You can completely copy last semester’s course, all the modules, assignments, due dates, and quizzes, into a new course shell. It does your grading for you! Not kidding!
John Warner is the opposite of a lazy teacher. He is right not to want technology to do his teaching for him. Nobody has written more, or more angrily, about what AI does to writing than John: “writing is thinking,” “large language models do not write, they produce syntax,” “we have to teach writing, not document production.” So will you join me in protesting Canvas with the same energy you protest AI?
Deans are not to blame for this. Nobody ever asked me, when I was a dean. I did not see how bad it was, as a dean. Had I known, I would have used my role to see about banning it altogether, and looking for alternatives. To the thousands of you signing petitions and open letters; to the thousands of you at places like Columbia, the University of Chicago, Syracuse, Virginia, Middlebury, and Hawaii who have gone back to blue books —every single one of your campuses is still using a far more harmful technology.
I’ve been trying to think of an analogy about why everyone is shouting about AI while using Canvas. My mind keeps going back to Hurricane Katrina in 2005, when the flood waters were rising and leaders were worried about sending out unregistered and uninsured boats to pick up people who would certainly drown. You should have seen the finger-pointing after. And don’t forget Jabbar Gibson, who had no driver’s license, “commandeered” an old school bus to rescue evacuees, and was almost stopped by officials. I get that many of you are fearful of a technology that seems perhaps like an uninsured boat driven by someone without a license. But my God, higher ed is a disaster zone in many places, largely because of technology like Canvas, and I’ll take AI for the rescue in a second.
Faculty members upload a syllabus with learning outcomes. When a student gets a passing grade, the software documents that learning took place and reports to various offices that certify to accreditors that learning is taking place. That’s it. Accreditation is about inspecting paperwork, not actual classes. Federal law has barred the Department of Education from requiring more since 2008. You see why universities want you to use Canvas.
There have been scattered, occasional protests. Two years ago CUNY Faculty protested objecting to being forced to use it and its $13.5 million cost. CUNY adopted the policy anyway for online courses.